NYC parents blast new DOE chancellor Melissa Aviles-Ramos’ ‘listening tour’
New York City’s new schools chancellor Melissa Aviles-Ramos has wrapped up her ambitious five-borough “listening tour” — with dozens of parents blasting it as nothing but a “PR stunt” full of “buzzwords” and “political agendas.”
The fact-finding mission, which started in late November and finished last week in Staten Island, was part of Aviles-Ramos’ promise to “open dialogue with school communities” after she was catapulted into the highly-paid position following her predecessor, David Banks’ shock exit.
New York City’s schools chancellor Melissa Aviles-Ramos succeeded the embattled ex-chancellor, David Banks. Matthew McDermott
Aviles-Ramos had said the tour would focus on efforts to ensure safety and wellness in Big Apple schools as well as how the Department of Education could foster greater support for teachers.
But disgruntled parents told The Post they felt “muzzled” and even “less informed” about the future of the largest school system in the country.
“Most of the people who got up to talk sounded like they were characters from a dystopian novel,” Queens dad Charlie Vavruska decried.
“All I heard were the same buzzwords or people’s political agendas,” he added.
Bronx mom Deb Alexander admitted she opted out of the tour because it all felt too “highly curated” — and that feedback she heard from other parents confirmed her skepticism.
“It would be so refreshing to hear ‘yes, that is a problem, we’re not sure how to fix it but we’re open to your suggestions.’ Engagement is not ‘listening,’ it’s a two-way street,” she said.
Aviles-Ramos addressed the criticism from parents in a sit-down interview with The Post, insisting the events were meant to be an “initial step.”
“What I would say to them is, we’re not perfect. We’re trying to get it right and we’re going to find more authentic and creative ways for them to get their voices out,” she said.
Aviles-Ramos had said the tour would focus on efforts to ensure safety and wellness in Big Apple schools as well as how the Department of Education could foster greater support for teachers. NYC Public Schools
On the education department’s website the “listening tours” were described as an event to be held in each borough of New York City “featuring structured discussions on topics such as special education, curriculum development, and mental health resources, culminating in a Q&A session.”
DOE staffers, however, eclipsed the number of parents and students attending each session.
The parents and students who did attend were split into groups of eight and asked to come up with one question, which was then massaged by a “facilitator” — typically a DOE staffer — and put to the chancellor and her panel of agency staff.
Topics brought up ranged from the contentious cell phone ban, remote schooling, class sizes and staffing concerns.
Class size law requires that K-3 classes have no more than 20 students, grades 4-8 have no more than 23 students, and grades 9-12 have no more than 25 students.
Despite the opportunity to air concerns, parents said the session ultimately didn’t feel “productive” or “insightful.”
“Why did I come out all this way,” an anonymous Brooklyn parent, who had her question on the math curriculum dismissed during the roundtable discussions, told The Post.
Disgruntled parents told The Post they felt “muzzled” and even “less informed” about the future of the largest school system in the country. X / Mayor Eric Adams
“I didn’t even feel like I could say how I felt during the discussion,” they added.
Meanwhile, Manhattan and Brooklyn were also the only two boroughs to even have a Q&A session.
Parents and students who attended sessions in the Bronx, Queens and Staten Island were instead asked to provide one comment to the panel — who would then silently take notes with the promise to address the feedback or concerns at an unspecified later date.
Aviles-Ramos waved off the backlash to the structure, saying, “of course, the structure doesn’t allow for every single person to ask a question.”
Parents also groaned that Aviles-Ramos has been tightlipped on policy since Banks’ earlier-than-expected departure — and that they feel “left in the dark” amid the leadership shakeup.
“I made a promise to the city that I would focus on civility and continuity, and you don’t bring in instructional initiatives in the middle of the school year when you’re already building out other ones,” Aviles-Ramos said of her tactic.
Families said they’re doubtful that the “listening tour” will foster in any real change.
“All chancellors have these listening tours. It starts with ‘yes, I’ll listen, I’ll take my notes,’ but how much of it will get done?” Queens parent Phil Wong bemoaned.
“If history serves us, only a very small set of problems will get addressed.”
It’s unclear how the data from the tour will inform upcoming policy.
Aviles-Ramos addressed the negative feedback, saying the tours were just the “initial step.” NYC Public Schools
Aviles-Ramos’ predecessor was pushed out of the top job by Mayor Eric Adams in October, rather than at the year’s end as originally planned, sources previously told The Post.
The move — which reportedly blindsided the ex-chancellor — came after he drew Hizzoner’s ire when he confided to city superintendents that he doubted the mayor could stay in power while facing federal criminal charges, sources said.
The mayor and City Hall officials also believed the blabbermouth Banks botched it and created confusion among parents about several initiatives, notably a potential cellphone ban and an expansion of early education seats, a source with knowledge said.
It also came after the feds raided the home Banks shares with Deputy Mayor Sheena Wright.